Most-Loved Magic!

Welcome To The Chaos

Indulgent Butters was created for people who don’t “kind of” love dessert. They live for it.

This is the brand for the ones who scrape the bowl, steal the frosting, order the extra topping, and always say yes to just one more bite.

Every jar of Indulgent Butters is built like a full dessert — not a flavor suggestion. Thick bases. Lavish swirls. Crunchy mix-ins. Gooey cores. And enough toppings to make you pause before your first spoon.

They’re bold, dramatic, colorful, overfilled, and unapologetically indulgent — because joy is not something you’re supposed to portion out.

From chaotic cookie explosions to marshmallow madness to monster-level mix-ins, every flavor is designed to feel like a late-night dessert run… except it lives in your pantry.

No rules. No guilt. No restraint. Just wildly good dessert in a jar.

Welcome to Indulgent Butters —where subtle went to die and indulgence took over. 

How The Chaos Is Built

Every Indulgent Butters flavor starts with a thick, rich peanut butter base — then it’s layered, swirled, folded, and overfilled by hand.

We don’t dump toppings in and hope for the best.

We build each jar in layers so every scoop hits differently — crunchy, gooey, creamy, chocolatey, marshmallowy, chaotic.

That’s why no two jars look exactly the same.

They’re hand-stacked desserts — not factory-spun spreads.

This is dessert construction. Not peanut butter production.

Spread The Love

"Experience the Silky Smooth Indulgence of Pure Butter Delight"

Yes you can!

Spread The Love

Cookie Chaos

Regular price $13.99
Regular price Sale price $13.99

It’s Party Time

Regular price $13.99
Regular price Sale price $13.99

Monster Madness

Regular price $13.99
Regular price Sale price $13.99

Honey Roasted Peanut Butter

Regular price $10.99
Regular price Sale price $10.99

Hot & Spicy

Regular price $10.99
Regular price Sale price $10.99

Cereal Killer

Regular price $13.99
Regular price Sale price $13.99

Bold & Savory

Regular price $10.99
Regular price Sale price $10.99

Brownie Points

Regular price $13.99
Regular price Sale price $13.99

Butter Toffee Peanut Butter

Regular price $13.99
Regular price Sale price $13.99

Jalapeno-Lime

Regular price $10.99
Regular price Sale price $10.99

Marshmallow Mayhem

Regular price $13.99
Regular price Sale price $13.99

Sweet & Spicy

Regular price $10.99
Regular price Sale price $10.99

Our bold, indulgent peanut butters come in a range of crave-worthy flavors, made to satisfy every sweet, savory, and spicy mood. Each jar is crafted for big scoops, easy spreading, and pure enjoyment whenever the craving hits.

Spoonfuls of Love

The creamy peanut butter is a game-changer! Perfectly smooth, rich, and packed with flavor. My morning toast has never been better

I'm obsessed with the almond butter. It's not too oily, not too dry—just perfect. You can tell it's made with care and high-quality almonds.

I tried both the peanut and almond butters and honestly can’t pick a favorite. They’re both so indulgent and delicious. You can taste the freshness!

This is hands-down the best peanut butter I’ve ever had. It's like dessert in a jar, without being overly sweet. My kids love it too!

The almond butter is my go-to now. It’s got a velvety texture that makes it perfect for smoothies, baking, or just eating by the spoonful!

I appreciate the clean ingredients and amazing taste. The peanut butter reminds me of old-school homemade spreads, only better

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything you need to know about our flavors, ingredients, orders, and shipping. If you don’t see your answer here, we’re always happy to help.

Is your peanut butter smooth or crunchy?

Most of our butters are smooth and thick, with mix-ins or toppings depending on the flavor.

Do the oils separate in your jars?

Yes, natural oil separation can happen. Just give it a good stir before enjoying.

How should I store my peanut butter?

Store in a cool, dry place. Refrigeration is optional and helps keep the texture firm.

Do you use preservatives?

No added preservatives. All of our butters are made fresh in small batches.

When will my order ship?

Orders are typically processed and shipped within the timeframe shown at checkout.